What Makes Impossible Burger Taste Like Beef
Sort by: Most Helpful
Most Helpful Most Positive Least Positive Newest
10/02/2013
These came out great! I substituted cooked quinoa for the dried bread great for more protein. On the adjusted serving serve to 4, I used 1 cup cooked quinoa.
02/15/2015
Cooking tip: Really make sure you cook the liquid off of the mushrooms and onions well, otherwise your burgers will be soft/ mushy. Suggestions for enhancing the flavor: 1/4 c tahini paste (adds a nice, nutty complexity to the flavor and helps bond the ingredients), 2Tb Worcestershire sauce (add to mushrooms while cooking), a sprinkle of Garam Masala or Curry (I have enjoyed both). This recipe also makes tasty meatballs for spaghetti-- just bake in small balls!
10/26/2013
The burger base itself is very delicious, but I needed to double the amount of breadcrumbs for the burgers to be able to stick together. They were still very delicate but handled carefully turned out delicious.
06/14/2015
Came out way better than I thought. I cut this down to 4 portions using 2 8oz packs of shrooms and still had enough for 6 patties. I added the garlic first, letting it brown and then the onion until it became a bit glassy, just because I'm used to that order. Cut the mushrooms finely before frying using a herb chopper - same with the onions. Used probably twice the oregano, two eggs, and a few handfuls of nacho cheddar cheese. Baked them 10 mins each side at 450. Crispy, meaty, juicy, non-crumbly and delicious. These could easily pass for real meat patties.
09/10/2014
These were really different. I don't think they taste like a burger, but more like a patty version of a vegetarian stuffed mushroom. Before being cooked the filling was almost like a mushroom heavy stuffing. Although, I do like that they set up, after they cook, as they cool. I wouldn't recommend this to a meat burger eater, but it might be a different change to someone tired of the flavor and texture of bean burgers. It was a little salty tasting to me, and I didnt love the soft chewy texture, but I think they will all be eaten by someone in my household. I made 1/2 recipe and got 7 patties with a #16 scoop.
12/27/2014
I have not tried this burger but it is enough like mine that I bet it is really good. Mine was so much like real meat that it was quite satisfying. I had lost my recipe so I was ecstatic to find one very close to mine. One difference is I chop the mushrooms into medium pieces and then fry them until they are golden and leathery. This is what gives them the meaty chewiness. I then add the other ingredients except the oatmeal. I am going to try my recipe with the oatmeal to see if it makes a difference. I don't use cheese in the mix and I add a tablespoon of soy sauce. I never liked the bean burgers that most vegie burgers are made of. They don't taste anything like a hamburger.
05/30/2015
I followed Hayley comment to add 2 tblspoons of Worcestershire sauce which is a great tip to give a real meaty flavor. I also added 1 tsp of paprika to give it a little kick and made sure to cook off all the juices. I also added additional breadcrumbs and 1 additional whole egg to get the patties to stick together better. The recipe was enough for 9 diner sized burgers, and I grilled them outside for about 15 minutes on medium direct heat flipping only once. They turned out delicious, and even the carnivores didn't miss the meat. This will be a regular staple for outdoor grilling season. Easy to make
01/27/2014
So good! My husband, who loves meat, and my 15 month old daighter both gobbled this up and loved it! I added extra garlic, oregano and parmesan cheese because we are big on flavor and wow was it good! very easy to make.
05/24/2015
I have really enjoyed this recipe. The first time I added quinoa as a previous reviewer suggested. Today I used rolled oats and also added a bit of siracha (1 tsp?) because I like spice. It was great as a 'hamburger' with avacado and tomato on top. This will become one of my regular vegetarian recipes for meatless Mondays.
08/21/2014
Had veggie burgers before and this one is one of the best I have ever made. The flavors are incredibly awesome! The patty had a crust on the outside and it was not mushy on in the inside, it's was firm and so yummy. My patty did not fall apart, I followed the instructions and it came out perfect. I topped my veggie patty with Swiss cheese and a slice of tomato on a whole wheat bun. I also had a side of my spicy sweet potato fries. Yummy! I will make this again.
08/19/2014
Chef John never disappoints!! This was an amazing recipe. I used cooked quinoa instead of breadcrumbs and oat flour instead of the whole oats. AMAZING!!
10/16/2014
I had already made the meatball version of this recipe (also on Chef John's website) and was absolutely amazing! Even my carnivorous family members loved it! I definitely recommend this recipe as it is.For more protein I sometimes substitute the breadcrumbs with fine bulgur.
02/09/2016
I don't really like mushrooms, but I picked this recipe because it had few ingredients and looked easy. These were fantastic! Didn't taste like mushrooms at all and they were so meaty and filling. So good I'll be using this as my veggie burger recipe now
02/23/2016
I turned this into a meatless meatloaf by baking it at 350 degrees for 45 minutes and letting stand for 10. I also made mushroom gravy for it and it was LOVELY!!!
12/16/2015
Dad complained the whole time I was cooking that we were eating veggie burgers for dinner--when he got the plate, he couldn't put it down. Only compliments!
08/22/2016
Made this twice now and both times were hit - even with meat lovers (including myself!). The base recipe was a fantastic base for personal modifications, so thank you for sharing. My adjustments: 3-part mix of shiitake mushrooms, brown field mushrooms and white button mushrooms. I found the mushroom combination really added more depth to flavour and texture. Used fresh thyme and oregano from my garden. Also added a sprinkle of freshly ground nutmeg and splash of Worcestershire sauce. TIPS: cut mushrooms into small pieces before pan frying, as this avoids messy chopping after cooking them; DO allow the mixture to rest for about 15 mins as suggested - the oatmeal and breadcrumbs will really soak up all liquids, which avoids a "watery" burger from falling apart.
01/10/2017
The best veggie burger yet. I am a true meat lover. But am always looking for good healthy meat substitute recipes. Never cared much for the bean based veggie burgers. The flavor and textures were not even close to ground beef. But seriously, with the first few bites of this burger, you really can't tell that this is not real meat. Low calorie, low carb meat substitute, what's not to love?
08/29/2014
Delicious! I added a little bit of garlic powder and onion powder to this recipe for extra flavour. Oh and I forgot to add the oats, but... it came out perfect. They were sticky enough to form nice burgers and after frying they became crispy from the outside and meaty inside. Yummy. Thanks for the recipe, I now make this every month.
06/18/2014
To be honest, I wasn't really expecting much from this recipe. But they turned out amazing. I had to make some adjustments because of available ingredients. I used scallions and added a little extra minced onion. I also used about half the amount of mushrooms that the recipe called for. I used 1/3 cups to make each potty. I cooked them on my George Foreman grill for about six minutes. I added a little cheese and left them on the grill for a further minute. I am very happy with this recipe and I will definitely make these burgers again ??
09/11/2016
This veggie burger is very tasty. I will definitely make them in the future. I did some tweeking. During the saute process I added small diced celery (2 ribs), a 1/2 of a fresh red pepper finely diced and a finely chopped blend of super greens (kale, spinach, chard). I ate mine on a whole wheat english muffin. I also replaced the oregano for a dried italian blend and added some dried parsley. I think they are good enough to use as Chef John's meatless meatballs.
09/17/2017
We made it vegan and it's amazing. We don't add cheese and we use Bob's Red Mill egg substitute. It's one of our favorite recipes!!
08/14/2015
Looks like Earls may be using this recipe as their Forager burger: https://earls.ca/news/new-gourmet-burgers-for-limited-time-only I tried a mushroom burger at Earls and loved it. Decided to GOogle a recipe and came across this. When you compare the description of the Forager to this, they seem identical.
12/07/2018
I used just oats instead of all the types of flours and substituted ground flax instead of egg to create a vegan and gluten-free delicious burger. One of the best burgers I've ever had!
04/06/2017
Loved this mushroom burger. It was easy to make. I would suggest putting all of the ingredients in bowls if you're going to follow along with chef John's video and chop the mushrooms into small pieces instead of slicing (John chops after the slices are sautéed and this makes chopping which does eventually does in the video, messy).
07/08/2018
I made this recipe and it is the best veggie burger I have ever tasted! The burgers brown up very nicely and are juicy and delicious. This recipe is my new favorite veggie burger.
06/07/2015
Once again, Chef John does not disappoint. I made these last night and my carnavore husband really liked them. The only changes I made was to dice the mushrooms prior to cooking and I added two generous shakes of Worcestershire to the mixture. It also helped to put the patties in the freezer so they were easier to cook without them falling apart. I froze the leftover patties and I can't wait to serve them again!
07/31/2015
Made this for supper and it turned out great! Hubby is a bit of a picky eater and he thought they were great! Omitted the cheese and forgot the oregano but otherwise followed the recipe. Will make again!
08/29/2018
This is the best veggie burger I have ever had!!!! I added Worcestershire Sauce and Smoked Paprika. I fried the burgers well because that's my preference... My husband LOVES meat!!! I tricked him and didn't tell him it wasn't ground beef and he couldn't tell!!!! He LOVED it!!!!!! This is an awesome recipe for someone who is trying to cut meat out of their diet!!!!!
05/08/2018
My burgers didn't hold together too well. Other than that, I enjoyed the taste!
08/20/2015
Pretty much followed the recipe, but added shredded carrots and removed oats. Sooooo Gooood! Topped with mozzarella. Yum!
07/25/2018
Used Baby Bella Mushrooms and substituted Smoked Gouda for the Parmesan. They were amazing!
06/26/2018
As a vegetarian of 12 years this was one of the least appetizing veggie burgers I've ever had. I was so excited to make this and the end result was very disappointing.
03/23/2018
This is one of many recipes that can be described as: "I just ate the best ______ in my life, and I made it myself, thanks to Chef John."
03/19/2017
Loved it! Pleasantly surprised!
11/09/2017
Very tasty, and you can't really tell the difference from a meat burger. I didn't have bread crumbs so I used wheat germ as a substitute; I believe it turned out well!
01/16/2019
OMG!!! This was the best Burger Veggie Burger I ever had. Even my picky 11 daughter liked it.
03/12/2019
i liked it. my bf wasn't a huge fan. probably wont make again.
10/05/2017
Made these tonight and oh wow!!! Made exactly as posted, no changes! By far, these were the best non meat burgers I've ever had and actually better than most of the meat burgers I've had. It was a looser texture, but dense enough to hold together with a little care taken while cooking. Very flavorful in a great way. It was actually a bit hard to tell that it wasn't just very tender mild ground beef. If you've ever had a juicy filet burger, you know this texture. We suggest they be served with provolone, brioche buns and perfectly ripe tomatoes. Yum!
03/22/2019
Great recipe, chop the mushrooms before cooking. Added 1/2 tsp thyme leaves
04/23/2019
Delicious, tastes like Money's mushroom burger
08/16/2017
These are the best veggie burgers I've made! I did add some Worcestershire sauce as suggested by a reviewer.
11/04/2018
This was a BIG hit! Hubby loved them. Looking forward to making them again very soon, and maybe varying the seasonings a bit. We also thought it might be good to form the patties ahead of time, wrap them tightly, and refrigerate, in hopes that they hold together a little better. Cooked the burgers in a nonstick skillet with a small amount of oil - I think it was important not to disturb them until they start getting browned. That also helps them hold together better. In any case, they were delicious and we will definitely make them again!
06/09/2017
Very good, but more of a vegetarian sloppy Joe than a veggie burger. Could use a lot more bread crumbs
01/18/2018
These came out great. I used a large onion and added a large red pepper to the recipe. The 24 ounces of mushrooms were taking a long time to release and evaporate their liquid. After the mushroom/onion/red pepper mixture was sufficiently cooked. I strained the liquid and ran the mixture through the grate blade on my Cuisinart. Following this, I strained the mixture again and continued with the rest of the ingredients. I skipped waiting 15 minutes and made about a dozen patties. I will definitely make this again.
08/23/2017
Great recipe! So simple but so flavorful. As a vegetarian for 15 years, I've tried MANY meatless burger recipes. This is one of the best. If you like mushrooms, you'll love this.
03/26/2018
These were great! They came out way better than I ever expected them too!! I thought they tasted great & had the texture & mouth feel of a hamburger! This will be my go to recipe for a veggie burger from now on!!
02/04/2018
yeah... absolutely delicious. being a vegetarian I loved it all the way...the flavor came out very well
11/04/2018
We loved this! One of my favorite veggie burger recipes so far. The only thing I would change is to half the recipe next time (cooking for 2 people) because we had a lot of leftovers.
02/15/2019
So good! Yum ??!. As a person who doesn't eat meat, it is nearly impossible to find a "burger" with good taste and as importantly, remarkably good texture. (Veggie burgers are mushie, and tofu burgers are dry.). I used steel-cut instead of rolled oats (because that's what I had on-hand). Also, found that the recipe made 9 sizable (2/3 cup raw) burgers. Very happy to have finally found an excellent , meatless "burger".
09/06/2018
So far, this is the best recipe I've tried for a mushroom burger. I did add more mushrooms and less bread crumbs. I added some liquid hickory smoke and a little soy sauce to the mix. I think letting the ingredients sit for 15 minutes is what made this recipe better than the others I've tried. The texture was almost there, but this is a great recipe to work with.
02/28/2015
Tasted good and surprisingly filling! Will make again.
08/28/2018
I didn't have oats so substituted cooked rice, chia and flax seeds. Added Worcestershire and Sriracha sauces. Will definitely make again!
03/18/2018
Added liquid smoke and Worcestershire for additional flavor. Also tried this with scallions and dried chives instead of yellow onion. Very good for non meat burger.
09/23/2017
I like this mushroom burger better than lentil burgers, tastes better. I substituted the eggs with 1/3 cup of plain Greek yogurt, and it tasted great.
04/11/2019
I made this last night (2 servings) for my husband who is a vegetarian. It made 2 patties with a little left over. He liked it very much and the recipe came together quickly. I was busy making 2 other dinners so I sort of rushed the prep but then put the mixture in the fridge. I made burgers when he was ready to eat and fried it on both sides for a few minutes but we normally bake our vegeburgers. He like it and I will make this again.
03/23/2015
I did this recipe but I add one chilly pepper chopped fine an extra egg and add mozzarella cheeses instead made a Sauce to top it 3tlbs of Mao 1tlbs of chilly paste 1tea spoon lemon juice salt and pepper to taste
03/26/2019
Outstanding! So tasty! I tried a pesto parmesan bread to make crumbs from; added wonderful flavor. My sister specifically requested these on her visit this week. Didn't freeze too well and didn't bake too well - I think my crumbs weren't dry enough yet. So just saute/fry them as the recipe states!
02/03/2019
I made sure that the mushrooms and onions were not runny. Also put them into an immersion blender to make everything much finer than cutting and found that the burgers really held up. Delicious and will be making them again but adding a can of black beans for protein.
07/17/2017
I made it exactly to the recipe and really enjoyed the patties. Next time I will try substituting the oats for cooked rice, just for fun.
03/24/2019
Incredible meatless patty.
08/29/2015
Yes I did ,not liking oats in a veggie burger so I added shredded carrots,chopped string beans,diceded and seeded tomatoes,and shredded and chopped up cabbage to your veggie burger and it was just good to me....
02/28/2020
This is honestly one of my favorite recipes. A few things to note: I have an egg allergy so did not add those, and was still able to form a burger that stayed together. I also make a full batch and keep it in a covered container that lasts several days, so can eat the rest later in the week. Finally, I do not think this tastes anything like a real burger as other reviewers noted / they may taste as good, but definitely taste different. Enjoy!
07/21/2019
These were amazing.
11/16/2015
I will definitely make this again. OUTSTANDING!!!!
11/23/2018
These taste great. I stacked them in tupperware raw on parchment for the freezer. Next time I make these I want a burger press to give them a nice shape, mine kind of fell apart around the edges. I might try adding another egg also? Yum.
12/07/2017
Finally! A meatless burger that has the same texture as meat! My husband refuses to eat mushrooms....so I didn't tell him at first. After I told him, he ate 4 more! Thank you!!!
05/29/2016
Really enjoyed this recipe! NOTE: You cannot grill these. They fall apart.
04/01/2017
These were so good! Even my 27 1/2 month old son gobbled these up!!!! Hubs LOVED them!!!!! Instead of mushrooms, I used angus beef and instead of bread crumbs, I used Cheez-It crackers, and I used grits instead of rolled oats and chopped potatoes instead of an onion. I also added paprika to give it a little KICK!!!! Hubs LOVED it!!!! He couldn't put them down!! He ate every last bite and then had explosive diarrhea for 18 hours!!!! Oh hubs!!!!
02/06/2015
Loved it! This was so good and so easy. I am trying to find ways to cut calories and still enjoy my food. This is going to become a common meal in my home. The only thing I did differently was put instant steel cut oats instead of rolled oats because that is what I had. Went great with Cauliflower (faux mashed potatoes).
03/30/2020
Delicious. I made in advance so let patties sit in fridge for probably 2 hrs. Flavors melded nice and helped solidify patties.
06/05/2015
This is my go-to veggie burger. I cook the mushrooms and onions then quickly put it in a food processor to get the consistency I like. Then I just cook until all the water has evaporated.
11/21/2014
awesome!!! we loved it!!
03/15/2018
This recipe made a truly great vegetarian burger! I brought a leftover one for lunch and my students thought I had quit being a vegetarian. Easy and delicious. This will be my go to veggie burger recipe. Thanks!
07/01/2020
This is the first veggie burger that was robust enough to make into a patty and not crumble when flipped. The flavor was great and it was oh so filling!
09/17/2021
I made this for dinner tonight. VERY tasty burger. I used a mix of Cremini, button and portobello mushrooms. Definitely a keeper. Thank you !!!!
07/16/2021
Just what I've been looking for: a tasty, non-soy veggie patty! Trader Joe's used to have a frozen mushroom-based patty that was pretty good and I always kept some on hand. They are no more. I made this exactly as written and we LOVED them! Husband couldn't believe the great flavor, consistency and eye appeal. Did use some Lea & Perrins to finish them off, gave a great crust. Thank you for this easy & and REALLY delicious recipe, Chef John!
05/25/2021
My hubby said he would choose this over a meat burger and all three kids gobbled it up. Winner winner mushroom dinner.
09/22/2021
We made this recipe and loved it. Our only modification was to add one more egg to bind the ingredients.
03/20/2020
Turned out as promised. Excellent
07/10/2016
I've tried many recipes for veggie burgers and Chef John's is by far the best ever! Followed recipe exactly and came out fantastic. This recipe is a keeper!
06/20/2016
I made this recipe from the Meatless Meatball Recipe which made really good meatballs - my grandson who was reared a vegetarian loved them and said they were the best veggie meatballs he had ever eaten - I will definitely make more. Jan JG
10/29/2016
They were AMAZING!!!
08/27/2019
I was afraid that the burgers would fall apart, they didn't. I made the recipe exactly as written, the burgers were great.
08/03/2019
great
08/15/2017
My life partner made this and he cooked it so good. Will be making these for the next cook out i attend to show ppl you dont need meat to make a good burger
09/20/2019
Turned out amazing i only used one egg for a regular package of regular basket.
04/13/2017
I've come back to this recipe over and over for five years now. These mushroom burgers are delicious. BUT, I've made some adjustments that I think are worth mentioning: You need to add an extra egg, and another 1/4 cup of bread crumb and 1/4 cup of oats. I don't cook the mushrooms in the first round with the onions and garlic. They cook enough when the patties go in the pan on medium heat. This was a happy accident one time when I forgot to cook the mushroom at first. Just be sure to give them enough time in the pan. About 4 minutes each side. They turn out great. They are just a touch more firm in the middle, as they aren't rubbery the way mushrooms can get when cooked to long, and it's also less oily. I add about three tbsp of fresh thyme to the garlic and onions in the pan. A huge thank you to Chef John who put this up years ago!
08/26/2018
Doubled the recipe the second time I made these burgers. I also used a recipe for homemade hamburger buns found elsewhere on this site. Both were well received.
02/14/2016
Added a bit more oregano just because I love oregano. It was easy to make and I will definitely make again.
03/11/2019
Definitely something I'll make again!! I added old bay to it and I must say, that was a great decision!
08/26/2018
For bread crumbs I broke up some hard bread from the store that had been buttered. It smelled a little sweet. I think it added to the flavor. These were really delicious and I will be making them again probably many times and trying some flavor variations. The texture was also good.
09/15/2017
My daughter preferred these compared to available vegetarian burgers. I also liked the taste and texture and found the burgers easy to make. Thanks for a great recipe!
02/19/2020
Easy to make. Was very good. Will be making it again soon
03/18/2020
Very good. I added some Worcester sauce as recommended by one reviewer.
05/02/2022
Why is olive oil listed twice in ingredients
12/11/2021
This recipe turned out great and was really delicious. I followed advice in some of the reviews and added some soy sauce, hot sauce and a little hoisin. I diced the mushrooms before cooking. I would definitely make this again!
06/22/2021
Love these! Added Worcestershire as another reviewer mentioned, also added bacon bits.
03/13/2021
Yum! I put the mushrooms, garlic and onion in a good processor then cooked it in the pan. The burgers fomed really well once everything was mixed together. Thanks for the recipe
06/11/2021
Excellent!!! I baked at 450 per side. Excellent!!!
Source: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/233999/mushroom-veggie-burger/
Post a Comment for "What Makes Impossible Burger Taste Like Beef"